Why Tim Wilson is wrong about “n______”

This article on the referential nature of language and our ‘Freedom Commissioner’s’ failure to understand it is excellent. I highly recommend you all read it.

Castan Centre for Human Rights Law

By  Patrick Emerton

A little over a week ago, Human Rights Commissioner Tim Wilson stated that he objects to current laws governing racially offensive behaviour because they allow members of particular communities to refer to one another using words that outsiders may not:

Asked whether he was referring to the word “n–––“, Mr Wilson said: “I won’t say it, but that’s right.”

Wilson then argued that repealing the relevant legislation – section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) – would restore “equality” to Australia’s discrimination laws.

This objection is radically mistaken. It rests upon a confusion about the nature of language, which on this occasion feeds a misguided political agenda.

Philosophers and cultural theorists have written a lot about the nature of language, expressing different views and coming from different perspectives. Racial, racialised and racist language is a particularly contentious matter. This blog adopts the approach of Hilary…

View original post 1,437 more words

Advertisements

Recommended Reading – Rights of Asylum Seekers.

Today I start what I hope to be a new series, that of adding links to news, editorials and blogs that I find interesting and/or thought provoking.

Today’s recommended reading comes from Melbourne’s Saturday’s Age published on 2nd of March. It is an editorial defending the right of refugee’s to seek asylum in Australia without the threat of indefinite detention.

I just wish Fairfax, and The Age more specifically, would follow it’s own advice when it comes to reporting upon the he said/she said politics of of the asylum debate. When it is dogwhistling, racist or a race to the bottom, call it so.

You can read the article here: http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/editorial/speaking-up-for-those-who-cant-20130301-2fbt2.html